Search
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/143, Tsiamitros
Receivability
The Tribunal reviewed the Applicant¡¯s request for management evaluation and found that only the decision not to consider him eligible for a temporary appointment through the Talent Pool, at the P-2 level, was receivable and subject to judicial review. Any other decision to which the Applicant referred in his submissions was consequently not receivable.
Merits
The Tribunal referred to the applicable legal framework as well as to the evidence on record and noted that the practice is to only consider experience at the G-6 level and above (or equivalent experience outside of the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµ...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/142, Brian Seales
The Tribunal was unpersuaded by the Applicant¡¯s claim that his participation in the Staff Day activities was ¡°essentially private conduct not involving [United Nations] resources¡± or that this was ¡°essentially a voluntary, social event¡±. The requirements for integrity, probity, honesty and truthfulness under the staff regulations and staff rules are not merely ¡°generic obligations¡± but are specifically intended to apply ¡°in all matters affecting [a staff member¡¯s] work and status¡±. [...] Accordingly, the Tribunal found that the established facts in this case amount to misconduct on the part of...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/141, Silva Roig
Under the definition of fraud, the Tribunal observed that the question of the Applicant¡¯s own benefit is not a required element to establish a finding of fraud. Rather, if found that by a misrepresentation, she intentionally deceived the 2017 and 2018 Staff Days and this actually or potentially caused prejudice to the 2017 and 2018 Staff Days, this is adequate.
The Tribunal found that, in the given circumstances, the Administration acted within the scope of its authority when finding that the Applicant had committed fraud. Accordingly, as per Asghar: (a) the Applicant misrepresented the...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1407, Lars Ronved
Mr. Ronved appealed.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal and affirmed the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT Judgment.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT erred in finding the application not receivable with respect to the refusal of a temporary promotion to the P-4 level.? The contested decision before the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was the decision to extend the SPA, which the Appellant timely challenged before the MEU and the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT.? The extension of the SPA and the denial to grant a promotion were two sides of the same decision, with the same time limits for management evaluation.? Therefore, the request for management evaluation of both decisions was...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/140, Maruschak
After consulting the Staff Regulations and Rules and the Respondent¡¯s submissions, the Tribunal has found nothing to contradict the Applicant that the breathalyzer test was conducted illegally.
The Tribunal will not accept evidence obtained in violation of the Staff Regulations and Rules.
The Tribunal finds that the Respondent has failed to discharge his burden of proof to show by clear and convincing evidence that the Applicant drove his vehicle after consuming alcohol.
The evidence is clear that the Respondent¡¯s argument that a Military Officer was authorized to conduct a breathalyzer...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1406, Kamal Karki
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT denied the Appellant¡¯s request for anonymity as the issue presented in his appeal was purely procedural and jurisdictional and did not involve any personal data which had to be protected.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT also denied the Appellant¡¯s request for an oral hearing, finding that that it would not assist the Appeals Tribunal in the expeditious and fair disposal of the case.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that because the Appellant filed his application 93 days after the receipt of the contested administrative decision, it was not receivable, absent waiver of the deadline of the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT observed that given...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/139, Mouchabek
The Applicant having failed to establish any illegality, procedural irregularity, bad faith or improper motivation in the Respondent¡¯s taking of the decision not to accept her request to withdraw her resignation, the application had to fail.
Had the Respondent not exercised his discretion to reject the Applicant¡¯s request to withdraw her resignation, he would have been compelled to rescind selection decisions already communicated and accepted by three other staff members. This would have constituted a breach of the employment contracts of the three staff members. This breach would have...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1405, Yonas Negasa
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the Secretary-General.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the administration of the written security affairs exam in the present case had not met the minimum standards detailed in Chhikara. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that the Administration had first administered the test, analyzed the results, and only then had decided that certain questions should be eliminated from consideration. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the unannounced and ex post deletion of questions from the written examination, after it had already been marked, on its very face violated the obligation to administer the test in a...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1404 , Alan George Blythe
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the staff member.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the recommendation report did not provide any explanation to understand the rationale of the non-selection decision. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that no information had been given in the course of the judicial proceedings either as to why the external candidate was the most suitable candidate. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that, for the sake of reasonableness, fairness and transparency, it was expected from the Administration to give relevant and true reasons supporting its ultimate choice. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had made an error of fact...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/138, Almoghayer
The Tribunal found unsubstantiated the alleged procecural and substantive irregularities in the lateral transfer of the Applicant to the position of CEO of GPH. The Applicant was well aware of both his lateral transfer and the business model of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµITAR, which is dependent on external funding. Also, the Applicant's letter of appointment clearly stated that his appointment was limited to availability of funds.
Moreover, the Applicant argued that, instead of being placed on SWLOP until the end of his temporary appointment, his contract should have been terminated, pursuant to para. 9(c) of AC...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1403, Francis N. Fultang
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the absence of a case management discussion and an oral hearing before the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was not a procedural error.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err in admitting and considering the memorandum of allegations of misconduct, as it was used by the Administration only to verify that circumstances warranting the placement of the Appellant on ALWP occurred. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT also found that the OIOS Investigation Report did not refer to the communications between the Appellant and his counsel, nor to exchanges during a mediation process, but only considered the Appellant¡¯s objective...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/136, Koura
The Applicant failed to convince the Tribunal that the Administration raised in him a legitimate expectation of renewal of his FTA. An erroneously raised personnel action without a written contract does not constitute a ground for legitimate expectation of renewal.
The Tribunal agreed with the Applicant that the Staff Regulations and Rules must be applied uniformly and consistently to staff members. United Nations procedures exist to facilitate fair and transparent substantive decisions, and the failure to abide by required procedures is no mere ¡°technicality¡±, but instead undermines...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1401, Mo?se Alain Nkoyock (Fils)
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT made several errors of law and of fact leading to a manifestly unreasonable outcome.
In particular, the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT erred in refusing to hold a hearing of evidence that Mr. Nkoyock sought to call to establish his defence to the allegations against him and to impeach the Secretary-General¡¯s witnesses. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT further erred when it failed to reach its own conclusions on disputed facts and relied overly on the internal investigation¡¯s findings. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT also erred in relying on evidence that it had ruled irrelevant and inadmissible...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/137, Naeem
The Tribunal recalled that receivability is a condition sine qua non for judicial review.
The Tribunal noted that by the time the Applicant filed his application, he had not been formally notified of the abolition of his post and the restructuring exercise was still ongoing. Up to the date of the judgment¡¯s issuance, the situation remained the same as showed by a November 2023 email from Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDP to the Applicant asking him to confirm his interest in the position of Programme Assistant at the G-5 level. So far, the Applicant is still serving at the G-6 level in Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDP Pakistan.
The Tribunal...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1402, Faten Hatim Al Dawoud
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the staff member.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT¡¯s reasoning for refusing an oral hearing because the staff member failed to establish that her appeal was receivable, was ex post facto and, thereby, erroneous.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that there was an error in the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT¡¯s calculation of compensation in lieu of rescission of the non-selection decision as there was no evidence to support the conclusion that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA would have found her unsuitable for the role at the end of the probationary period.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT was of the view that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT¡¯s methodology of fixing...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2023/135, Kirby
The Tribunal found that the Applicant failed to show by clear and convincing evidence that she was denied a fair chance of promotion. The contested decision was lawful as the Administration appropriately exercised its discretion in matters of staff selection. The Tribunal found no evidence to support the Applicant¡¯s view that her involvement with ¡°contentious¡± discussions with DGACM management as a Staff Union representative has any bearing on the interview process for the contested position.
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1399, Michel Raymond Marie Rixen
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the Secretary-General of WMO.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the staff member was seeking to adhere to an agreed variation to his contract which, in return for foreshortening his period of employment, entitled him to a termination indemnity. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had been correct in establishing a direct and negative effect, brought about by the implementation of the contested decision, as a condition for receivability.
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT was of the view that WMO¡¯s decision purporting to rescind its agreement affected the staff member¡¯s established career and personal...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1400, Lanla Kamara-Joyner
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err in finding that the facts underlying the written reprimand were established. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT agreed that Ms. Kamara-Joyner¡¯s advocacy for an individual staff member was outside of her roles and duties in both her capacity as a Conflict Resolution Officer for Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµOMS and as President of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµPAD. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that Ms. Kamara-Joyner failed to expressly seek approval for the conflict of interest between her two roles and refused to follow instructions on removing the conflict of interest. Accordingly, she was subject to a disciplinary or administrative measure. The...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1398, Sergio Baltazar Arviz¨² Trevino
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that several months after the Secretary-General had been notified of the Judgment, the only action taken was that some responses had been elicited from four staff members alleged in the complaint to have engaged in misconduct and that ¡°these responses alongside the 22 pages and 18 annexes¡± to the complaint were under review.
Noting the justification of the Secretary-General for the inaction that in the instant matter, no specific time had been set for execution, the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Administration had not acted as promptly as per the obligations imposed on it, "within a...
2023-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1397, Ibrahim Ahmad Fanous
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT did not err in its award of in-lieu compensation. It appropriately considered Mr. Fanous¡¯ chance of selection for the post when it stated that it considered there was no guarantee of a future selection. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT applied a context-specific lump sum amount. It considered the likelihood of selection and Mr. Fanous¡¯ salary at the time. It made a determination that was fair and just in the present case but also took a principled approach that considered all relevant considerations.
As to Mr. Fanous¡¯ request for moral damages, with regard to the First and...