Search
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1201, Annette Guetgemann
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the decision of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT that the application in relation to the non-renewal decision was moot because the non-renewal decision never materialised was correct. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the non-renewal decision was overtaken by the Appellant¡¯s separation for health reasons and that the Appellant had not challenged the actual decision that ultimately resulted in the termination of her employment. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had no obligation to consider the merits of the superseded decision once it correctly found that the application was moot. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err in finding that the...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1199, Nazma Banaras Khan
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the Secretary-General. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT erred in law in finding that the Administration was not legally allowed to consider seniority or career advancement in the selection process. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that it was entirely proper to make a choice between two recommended candidates based partly on their respective seniority and time already served at a particular grade. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT also erred in essentially reversing the burden of proof by requiring the Secretary-General to show that the factors considered were explicitly provided for in the legal framework rather...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1213, Sandra Hilaire-Madsen
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the Secretary-General against Judgment No. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2021/032. It also considered a cross-appeal by Ms. Hilaire-Madsen claiming that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT should have rescinded the Administration¡¯s non-renewal decision and awarded her alternative compensation as well as compensation for moral damages.
As regards the lawfulness of the non-renewal decision, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that under the specific circumstances, at the material time of the contested non-renewal decision at the end of December 2018, from the point of view of a fair-minded objective observer, with the information available at...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1206, Torek Farhadi
Mr. Farhadi appealed. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed Mr. Farhadi's contention that the successful candidate had not been subject to the mandatory vetting procedure. The mere indication by the Hiring Manager of the fact that ¡°[b]oth candidates have worked with women and trade previously¡± under the rubric ¡°Reference check¡± was not sufficient to conclude that there were no actual reference checks. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that more importantly, reference checks normally take place only once the selection has been concluded, and in the present case, Mr. Farhadi was not selected. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that in...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1189, Louis Savadogo
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that in this case, the JAB made not a decision, but rather a recommendation to the Registrar of the ITLOS, who in turn, purported to make the decision about Mr. Savadogo¡¯s appeal. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT recognized that the ITLOS changed and consolidated the relevant Staff Regulations and Rules so that the JAB now makes decisions (from which appeals may be brought to the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT) rather than, as occurred in this case, recommendations to the Registrar of the ITLOS, which the Registrar may or may not accept. However, this amendment came too late for the parties in this case. Thus, the original...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1194, Jafar Hilmi Wakid
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT did not commit an error in procedure, such as to affect the decision of the case pursuant to Article 2(1) of the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT Statute. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT rejected the argument that the fact that the Appellant did not receive the recordings of the hearing or transcript affected the decision of the case. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant merely repeated arguments raised before Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT accepted Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT¡¯s finding that the Appellant had ample opportunity to respond to allegations and provide comments on the investigation report and exhibits. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT made fundamental errors of...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1233, null Secretary-General
The Secretary-General appealed. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT allowed the Secretary-General¡¯s appeal and set aside the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s Judgment. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the correct way to make the comparison to ensure that the minimum increase in net base salary under Staff Rule 3.4(b) is achieved for the staff member is to compare both remunerations shorn of their COL and post adjustment elements and of Ms. Gonzalez Vasquez¡¯s assessments under each. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that although not perfect because of the potential variability of Ms. Gonzalez Vasquez¡¯s personal assessments under each, it achieves the required comparator using the GS net...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1232, Baker Okwir
Mr. Okwir appealed. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT correctly held that the OiC/OIOS had the authority to take the decision not to investigate Mr. Okwir¡¯s allegations. As Section 4.3 of ST/SGB/2019/2 provides that all subdelegations issued by the predecessor shall remain valid unless otherwise withdrawn or modified by the successor, the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT concluded that the mere fact that the new USG/OIOS began her term did not make subdelegations by the predecessor invalid. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT concluded that on 25 October 2019, both the ASG/OIOS and the newly appointed USG/OIOS were competent to make the decision. The new USG...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1234, Gabriel Branglidor
Mr. Branglidor appealed. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that the totality of the evidence confirmed the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s conclusion that Mr. Branglidor was well aware of the untruthfulness of the forms when he submitted the second claim for the regular disbursement of the education grant. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT was satisifed that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was correct when it held that the act of misconduct was committed with knowledge and intent. Even though the misconduct did not lead to any actual prejudice, since the Administration recovered the payment made in advance and did not pay any further education grant, Mr. Branglidor¡¯s endeavor could have...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1220, Dzenan Viteskic
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err when it held that ST/AI/2017 was the governing legal framework applicable to the case. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that joint representation by Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµ-Women, where the Appellant currently served, and Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµMIK, where the events in dispute occurred, was justified. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the circumstances also justified the granting of an opportunity to supplement the initial reply (and a corresponding right to reply). Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that, given that the Appellant had not contested the joint representation before Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT at the time and having been afforded the opportunity to answer the supplementary...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1198, Mehmet Selman Erg¨¹den
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Mr. Erg¨¹den¡¯s decision when he elected to be on the local-currency track was irreversible unless the pre-conditions as set out in Paragraph 31(b) and 38(e) of the PAS were met. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Mr. Erg¨¹den did not meet those pre-conditions and that, as the decision of the Standing Committee was in observance of these provisions, there was no basis to grant Mr. Erg¨¹den the right to revert to the USD track. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that there was no proper basis to compel the Chief Executive of Pension Administration to suspend Turkey from the two-track system. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal and...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1231, Sergio Arvizu Trevino
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant had no standing to seek consideration by a full bench. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that to the extent Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT engaged in a fact-finding exercise of its own, this was not a legitimate exercise of its competence. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Administration¡¯s failure to provide adequate reasons for the contested decision resulted in the contested decision being unlawful. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Administration¡¯s failure to exercise its discretion with regard to carrying out an investigation also rendered the contested decision unlawful. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT allowed the appeal in part. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT vacated the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT Judgment by...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1217, Ajay Sud
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT disagreed. First, the Tribunal reasoned that the JAB did not engage in a critical analysis of the facts of the case and did not apply the law to the facts in order to ascertain whether the exercise of discretion was lawful. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT concluded that the JAB Decision was arbitrary and did not meet the minimum requirements of providing a reasoned analysis. Second, on the merits, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found the Administration did not notify the staff member of his shortcomings in sufficient time. Neither did It provide the staff member with explicit measures against which his performance would be evaluated. Third...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1203, Torek Farhadi
Mr. Farhadi appealed. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed Mr. Farhadi's request for compensation for the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT's delay in delivering its Judgment within a reasonable timeframe. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that Article 9(1)(b) of the Appeals Tribunal Statute authorises the Appeals Tribunal only to award compensation for harm deriving from an administrative decision, not from a delay in the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s proceedings. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed Mr. Farhadi's contention that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT shifted the burden of proof. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT was satisfied that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had assessed all the elements of evidence in the record and correctly found that...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1230, Ratnanjali Koduru
Ms. Koduru appealed. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err in law or fact in concluding that Ms. Koduru¡¯s case was fully and fairly considered. Specifically, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found no error in the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s finding that Ms. Koduru had failed to meet the burden of proof that the decision was based on ulterior motives and a protracted pattern of harassment, as well as to establish a causal link between the alleged incidents and the challenged administrative decision not to renew her fixed-term appointment. Rather, such a decision, as correctly determined by the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT, was a reasonable and proper exercise of the...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1197, Antonio Ponce-Gonzalez
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was correct when it found that the Appellant should not have been treated differently from other candidates without justification and that proceeding in the manner suggested by him would have breached the other shortlisted candidates¡¯ rights to fair and full consideration. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the only logical conclusion to be drawn was that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was correct in its finding that there was a regrettable error in the temporary job opening when it exempted the previously rostered candidates from any further assessment, and that this error was later rectified when all short-listed...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1190, Emma Reilly
Ms. Reilly filed an application for correction. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that her application was in substance both an application for correction and revision. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the application. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the corrections sought were of no material relevance to the outcome and reasoning of the judgment. With respect to one correction sought, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that the Secretary-General conceded that he had furnished the Appeals Tribunal with incorrect information - Ms. Reilly was on special leave with pay for four rather than six days in October 2019. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT, however, found that that was not a decisive fact, as it...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1191, Abdalla Abdalla
Mr. Abdalla filed an application for revision and interpretation of Judgment No. 2021-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1078, claiming that the filing of the Secretary-General¡¯s appeal had a suspensive effect on the ongoing proceedings in the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT, that therefore the extended time limit to file an application would not have elapsed, and thus his ultimate application should be received; and that once Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT had dismissed the Secretary-General's appeal, it should have remanded the case for further adjudication. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that Mr. Abdalla had failed to point to any statement or consideration in the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT Judgment which would...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1188, Julieta Coca
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT agreed with the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT that the factual circumstances surrounding the staff member¡¯s transition from the temporary appointment to the FTA demonstrate that she was ¡°re-employed¡± on 1 February 2016. The Organization did not treat her as being continuously employed and it proceeded with an actual separation from service and dealt with the effects that this entails, such as payment of her accrued annual leave while serving on the temporary appointment. The Tribunal further noted that the staff member was re-employed, and not reinstated. The Tribunal remarks that because the temporary...
2022-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1187, Applicant
The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was faced with two irreconcilable versions of the case, and thus it was necessary for the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT to satisfy itself on the credibility and reliability of the various factual witnesses and probabilities. This task was made especially difficult for the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT since the relevant witnesses did not present their evidence in person. In this case, the evidence presented by the Secretary-General was of an exceedingly limited nature and value. The Secretary-General relied exclusively on the contents of the written report of the OIOS investigation, which was entirely hearsay and, in some instances...