蘑菇视频DT/2013/066, Chikuhwa
The 蘑菇视频DT found that the decision that the Applicant was not eligible for consideration for conversion to a permanent appointment was lawful.
The 蘑菇视频DT found that the decision that the Applicant was not eligible for consideration for conversion to a permanent appointment was lawful.
The Applicant contended that the transfer decision was unlawful in that it was arbitrary and adopted and implemented in breach of mandatory procedures and that 蘑菇视频CTAD senior management acted in bad faith and with ulterior motives when doing so. The Respondent submitted that the 蘑菇视频CTAD senior management acted within its margin of discretion and on properly reasoned grounds based on the Applicant’s skills and qualifications and the operational needs of 蘑菇视频CTAD both in New York and Geneva. The Tribunal found that the reasons provided to the Applicant for his transfer were not justified by the...
The Respondent submitted that the application was filed out of time as the Applicant had submitted it after 5 p.m. (closing hour of the New York Registry) on the last filing day. The 蘑菇视频DT found that the Statute and the Rules of Procedure provide that applications are to be filed within 90 calendar days from the date of notification of the outcome of management evaluation, and, therefore, the applicant had until the expiration of the last calendar day of the filing period to file his application, regardless of the working hours of the Registry. Having done so, his application was receivable...
The Applicant was denied eligibility for conversion because in 2006 she had a break in service of eight days, which interrupted the continuity of her service. The 蘑菇视频DT found that the main issue in the case was whether the break in service in 2006 can be taken into account for the purpose of conversion to a permanent appointment. The 蘑菇视频DT found that the break in service that took place in 2006 shall not be taken into account because the Applicant was induced into taking it, without proper legal basis, as a condition for her employment in New York. The 蘑菇视频DT ordered rescission of the decision...
The administrative decision that was being challenged was made on the recommendation of the Advisory Board on Compensation Claims (“ABCC”). The Tribunal found that the ABCC was correct in rejecting the Applicant’s claim for compensation for injuries suffered from the car accident.
The Applicant was informed of the decision to not renew his contract, based on the “serious weaknesses in his performance” on 27 October 2008. Consequently, any request for administrative review of the decision to not renew his contract should have been filed within 60 days from the notification of the contested decision.The Applicant, due to the very negative review and comments contained in his PER, was on notice of the potentially inaccurate information contained therein its receipt in August 2009. The 15 June 2010 transmittal of the OIA investigation report, while potentially providing the...
With respect to the first contested selection process, the 蘑菇视频DT found that the Applicant was properly considered for it but was determined as not suitable. With respect to the second contested selection process, the 蘑菇视频DT found that the Respondent’s explanation that the post was not filled due to reasons not related to the Applicant’s candidacy was credible. The 蘑菇视频DT rejected the application.
The Tribunal rejected the Respondent’s argument that this was a case of non-renewal and found that the Applicant’s fixed-term contract was terminated on the grounds of alleged unsatisfactory performance for the period of 2007 to 2010. The 蘑菇视频DT found that the performance evaluation report (“PER”) for 2010 cannot be lawfully relied upon to justify the finding of unsatisfactory performance as the Applicant had no opportunity of a meaningful rebuttal. Therefore, the termination of the Applicant’s contract on the basis of poor performance was unlawful. The 蘑菇视频DT also found that no proper...
The Tribunal found that the Applicant was not entitled to any compensation for loss of earning and benefits because the case corned the Ethics Office’s decision that the Applicant had not been retaliated against and not the circumstances regarding his separation from 蘑菇视频DP. As for non-pecuniary damages, the Tribunal found that it was difficult to envisage a worse case of insensitive, high-handed and arbitrary treatment in breach of the fundamental principles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, including Articles. 1, 3, 6, 7, 8 and 9. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the failures...
By deciding not to undertake the written test for the two posts, the Applicant removed the hiring manager’s capacity to effectively compare her skills to that of the other candidates. By not taking the written test the Applicant effectively withdrew from the entire approved selection process and she could no longer enjoy the right of being evaluated appropriately, and against the pre-approved criteria. Consequently, none of the Applicant’s rights were breached during the selection exercise for these posts. The Applicant claims that she should have been selected for either of the two posts even...