Search
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1069, Civic
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the Secretary-General and a cross-appeal by Ms Civic limited to the extent to which Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT dismissed her claim of compensation for pecuniary damage (loss of opportunity). On loss of opportunity, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err when it found that the irregularity of cancelling the Appellant¡¯s performance appraisal and the failure to promptly issue another one did not suffice to demonstrate a significant chance or realistic prospect of her retaining another position within the Organisation. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the irregularity was inconsequential for the purposes of the...
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1070, Halidou
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT erred in attaching no weight to the medical evidence and in finding that the disciplinary measure imposed was based on an incorrect determination of the nature and gravity of the assault. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that there were other more important factors to consider, including the fact that the Appellant was a staff member in charge of local security and that his conduct was an abuse of authority and oppressive of a local inhabitant. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT recalled that the test of proportionality required a comparison between the misconduct and the sanction, not the investigation and disciplinary...
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1071, Krioutchkov
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Organisation correctly excluded the Appellant from the recruitment process for not meeting the minimum education requirement, as he had not entered his educational credential accurately. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that the Appellant had had access to the Inspira Applicant¡¯s Manual and World Higher Education Database, which was embedded into Inspira. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant¡¯s argument that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT failed to implement the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT judgment to carry out additional fact-finding on the issue of whether Inspira reflected the variety of the educational systems of all Member States equally in 2016...
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1073, Erik Kennes
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT affirmed Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s position regarding the moment the Appellant knew or reasonably should have known of the content and finality of the decision and that it triggered the time limit to request management evaluation. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT further affirmed Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s position that the Appellant¡¯s request for management evaluation was time-barred. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT, however, noted that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT should have found the application not receivable ratione materiae, which is the case if there is no timely request for management evaluation, rather than ratione temporis. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT further noted that this error by Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not adversely affect...
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1061, Abu Osba
As a preliminary matter, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that an oral hearing was not necessary and would not assist in the expeditious and fair disposal of the case as the Appellant had not provided grounds for an oral hearing beyond seeking to confront the witnesses and comment on existing evidence. Whilst Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant failed to identify any errors of law or fact by Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT as required under Art 2(1) Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT Statute, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT did go on to consider his appeal as he was not represented. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT had correctly applied the standard of review for disciplinary cases and that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT¡¯s exercise...
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1047, Orabi
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal of judgment No. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA/DT/2019/070 by the Commissioner-General of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT did not commit any error when it concluded that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA had failed to consider the Applicant¡¯s personal and humanitarian reasons in the impugned decision. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT correctly concluded that relevant matters (personal and humanitarian reasons) had been ignored in the exercise of the Commissioner-General¡¯s discretion. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal and affirmed the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT judgment.
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1048, Ross
The Applicant sought revision of judgment 2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-944 pursuant to Article 11(1), which sets out strict and exceptional criteria that must be met. The Applicant alleged he became aware, in January 2020, that the Inspector General¡¯s Office (IGO) of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµHCR had not made a finding on whether the hiring manager¡¯s conduct amounted to misconduct. The Applicant contended that the Respondent had made misleading comments to Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT, which led the latter to erroneously conclude that the IGO had investigated and determined that no misconduct had occurred. In addition, the Applicant sought leave to submit...
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1057, Nsengiyumva
On the Appellant¡¯s claim that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT Judge was biased, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant¡¯s specific allegations were not made out and any missteps in the conduct of the hearing did not warrant interference with the result. On the Appellant¡¯s claim that his supervisor harassed him to the extent that his actions were mitigated substantially, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that even if the Appellant established that there was a dysfunctional relationship between him and his supervisor, this could not have had the effect of mitigating his actions significantly, such were the scale and duration of his misconduct. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT...
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1058, Nadeau
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by Mr Nadeau of Order No. 184 and his request that both Order Nos. 184 and 169 be rescinded. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that he did not demonstrate that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had clearly exceeded its jurisdiction or competence in rejecting his request for new documents to be introduced into evidence. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that the issue could be raised on appeal against the final judgment on the merits. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT is competent to review whether certain facts remained unresolved at the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT level and to consider the need for factual determinations based on the whole of the relevant evidence. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal.
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1059, Bezziccheri
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an application for revision of judgment No. 2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-948 by Ms Bezziccheri. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered Ms Bezziccheri¡¯s claim that ST/AI/2019/1 was unknown to her and Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT at the time the judgment was issued. Noting the three elements that an applicant for revision must establish cumulatively before a final judgment of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT can be revised, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the fact that ST/AI/2019/1 was known to Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT when it issued its judgment (as it had been referred to therein) was sufficient in and of itself to fail the cumulative test. Further, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that ST/AI/2019/1 was not determinative of Ms...
2020-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1046, Ashhab
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that, although no performance evaluation process was legally required for termination, an appropriate procedure should have been followed. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA failed to indicate that the contract would be terminated before its expiration date if the staff member did not improve his performance, and the lack of fair warning rendered the decision to terminate unlawfully. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT granted the appeal in part, rescinded the termination decision, and ordered reinstatement, with an in-lieu compensation of two months¡¯ net base salary.
2021-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1077, Icha
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had not failed to properly exercise its jurisdiction by refusing to convene a second case management discussion. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that, regarding the question of whether Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT failed to address the Appellant¡¯s factual arguments challenging the legality of the abolition of her post, the appeal was without merit; the Appellant only reargued her case and did not establish that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT erred in fact or in law about this issue. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held, however, that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT erred in deciding that the Appellant had failed to rebut the presumption that the selection of Mr D R-B, given that the selected...
2021-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1075, Nadeau
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err in assessing the evidence presented. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was correct in its finding that i) it would seem that the Appellant¡¯s situation with his former FRO had actually been resolved since they no longer worked together; ii) the Appellant¡¯s eventual temporary reassignment would appear to have been a very reasonable further solution to bring him out of an office environment in which he obviously continued to feel uncomfortable, and iii) it would fall within the Administration¡¯s discretion whether to enact any of the three measures proposed by the Appellant. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT...
2021-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-1076, Haidar
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered both appeals by the Secretary-General and by Mr Hussein Haidar. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT denied the request for an oral hearing. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err in concluding that the facts, on which the disciplinary measure was based, had been established by clear and convincing evidence. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT correctly concluded that the established facts legally amounted to serious misconduct. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not commit an error in procedure such as to affect the decision of the case when considering one of the statements. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found no error in Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s finding that the measure of...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2020/185, Modey-Ebi
The Tribunal found that the Administration discharged the burden of establishing that misconduct had occurred with regard to most of the allegations and that the established facts legally amounted to misconduct under the regulations and rules. There were no due process violations in the investigation and in the disciplinary process leading up to the disciplinary sanction against the Applicant.
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2020/184, Julliard, Simonpieri, Maridor & Barla
The issue at stake is whether the non-selection decisions were lawful and, if not, what remedies are to be awarded. The scope of the Tribunal¡¯s jurisdiction in selection and appointment matters is twofold: 1) to evaluate if the Administration has followed the pre-established procedures and staff members were given full and fair consideration and 2) to examine if the decision is not blatantly unreasonable, arbitrary or illegal. The Tribunal finds that the fact that the Administration decided to consider the result of the LABEL test when examining applications for the job opening does not amount...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2020/181, Armand
The Tribunal found that whereas Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµSOS had called upon the Applicant to comply with the court order under the sanction of deductions, in fact, there were no deductions decided or effected. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµSOS¡¯s actions were only prefatory. The Tribunal, therefore, held that the application was not receivable for want of a reviewable administrative decision. The application was dismissed.
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2020/182, Toson
The impugned decision did not produce any direct legal consequence on the Applicant¡¯s terms of appointment or his contract of employment since he had an FTA which did not carry any expectancy, legal or otherwise, of renewal or conversion, irrespective of length of service. The Tribunal held that the Applicant¡¯s assertion that he had a legitimate expectation of a two-year contract renewal as was usually the case ran counter to the clear and consistent jurisprudence of the Appeals Tribunal that the renewal of the appointment of a staff member on successive contracts did not, in and of itself...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2020/183, Toson
The impugned decision did not produce any direct legal consequence on the Applicant¡¯s terms of appointment or his contract of employment since he had an FTA which did not carry any expectancy, legal or otherwise, of renewal or conversion, irrespective of length of service. The Tribunal held that the Applicant¡¯s assertion that he had a legitimate expectation of a two-year contract renewal as was usually the case ran counter to the clear and consistent jurisprudence of the Appeals Tribunal that the renewal of the appointment of a staff member on successive contracts did not, in and of itself...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2020/180, Applicant
The Applicant did not prove that any exceptional circumstance beyond her control prevented her from filing the application on time. The Applicant¡¯s request for anonymity is granted to ensure the protection of the medical information discussed in the case. Related