Search
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2019/053, Fortis
Receivability. The Applicant took no action to challenge the payment made to his wife, and the collection that would necessarily follow, within the 60 day period provided for in Staff Rule 11.2. At the time of submitting his request for management evaluation on 23 June 2017, the said deadline had experide several months ago. The Tribunal finds therefore concluded that the application is irreceivable rationae materiae (Egglesfield 2014-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-402) concerning the recovery by the Administration of the payment of EUR 7,000 made to the Applicant's wife. The application is also irreceivable rationae...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2019/052, Aboua
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT held that the Applicant had not met the evidentiary burden of showing that the Administration made an express and firm commitment in writing to extend his appointment and that conversely, the evidence showed that, in accordance with its Transition Plan, the Mission had no intention of maintaining the Applicant¡¯s post and proceeded with the downsizing. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT held that the Report of the Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions did not require Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµOCI to renew the Applicant¡¯s appointment, neither did it alter Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµOCI¡¯s obligation to implement the phased drawdown in accordance...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2019/051, Dreifeldt Laine
Applicant withdrew all allegations and claims, there being no matter for adjudication by the Dispute Tribunal and the case is closed.
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2019/049, Oakes
The Tribunal held that only the decision of 10 August 2016 was controlling because it informed the Applicant in no uncertain terms that his P-4 appointment was going to be voided. He requested management evaluation on 7 October 2016, which was well within the 60-day delay set out in staff rules 11.2(a) and 11.2(c). This claim was therefore receivable. Revoking the Applicant¡¯s appointment ab initio was disproportionate and thus illegal. Recovery of the Applicant¡¯s paid emoluments was accordingly without basis. The refusal to pay the Applicant¡¯s benefits attaching to service in Mogadishu at the...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2019/050, Wesslund
Art. 8.1(i) of the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT Statute provides that in cases where a management evaluation of the contested decision is required, as in this case, an application shall be receivable if it is filed within the statutory time-limits. A staff member who has received an adverse decision about a claim cannot purport to unilaterally withdraw it and resubmit it with allegedly new evidence to attempt to have a new decision. In this case, there is not even new evidence. There would never be finality or certainty in respect of any decision if this were to be permitted. Such conduct, aimed at resetting the time...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-916, Agha
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT finding that the non-renewal decision constituted a separation decision for abandonment of post was not supported by the evidence and was, therefore, an error in fact and in law. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the evidence clearly established that the non-renewal decision was solely based on the Appellant¡¯s unauthorised absence from duty. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT erred in law in distinguishing Abdallah (judgment No. 2010-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-091) from the present case. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that there was overwhelming evidence that the Applicant did not meet his burden of proving that the Administration did not act...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-917, Farzin
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the appeal was entirely without merit. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT upheld the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT finding that the application was not receivable as the Appellant had waived the relevant right and therefore did not have standing. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT affirmed, albeit for different reasons, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s final legal conclusion that the Applicant¡¯s application was not receivable ratione materiae. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that there was no reviewable administrative decision in the Appellant¡¯s application. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had no primary legal or factual basis from which it could conclude that the Applicant had properly sought judicial review of a...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-918, Nadasan
On the delay before Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT agreed that the delay was unfortÄ¢¹½ÊÓÆµATe but held that the Applicant had not demonstrated that it was a procedural error affecting the outcome of the case. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT erred in exercising its case management discretion when it refused the request for an oral hearing, but that this error did not affect the decision of the case. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err as there was clear and convincing evidence that the Applicant had committed sexual harassment. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the disciplinary sanction of separation from service with compensation in lieu of notice and...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-919, Krioutchkov
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the Secretary-General. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the issue of whether the staff member¡¯s application was pre-screened by a Human Resources Officer was irrelevant in determining whether his candidature received full and fair consideration. On the basis that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT failed to enquire as to what options were available to the staff member on Inspira at the time of application, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s findings that Inspira did not reflect the variety of the educational system of all the Member States equally and that the staff member¡¯s candidature had not been afforded full and fair...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-914, Oglesby
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that at the time of his separation from service, the former staff member was not married to his husband; their same-sex relationship did not enjoy similar status to marriage under the law of the US; the Regulations did not afford retrospective recognition of their marriage in 2018; and the Regulations specifically regulated the situation of the former staff member by providing for an annuity under Article 35ter. Therefore, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT concluded that under the express terms of Articles 34 and 35, the former staff member¡¯s spouse was not entitled to a survivor¡¯s benefit. Nonetheless, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-915, Yasin
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the Secretary-General. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT properly reviewed the contested decision in accordance with the applicable law and established the critical facts of the case. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had a broad discretion to determine the admissibility of evidence and the weight to be attached thereto and that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s conclusion was consistent with the evidence. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s conclusion that the impugned decision was unlawful was correct, albeit for different reasoning. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the facts underpinning the administrative decision to issue the staff member a...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-903, Afeworki
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant did not produce sufficient evidence to support her allegations of bias, discrimination, and/or improper motives. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that it had examined all of the grounds raised in the appeal and held that there was no evidence that the Administration did not act fairly, justly, and transparently throughout the restructuring process. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant failed to establish any error in law or fact to support her case for a reversal of the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT judgment. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal and affirmed the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT judgment.
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-904, Prempeh
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant did not fall under any of the categories of potential applicants and had no legal standing before Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that, accordingly, the Appellant had no standing before Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT and therefore Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT had no competence to address the merits of her claims. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal and affirmed the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT judgment.
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-905, Ghusoub
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT rejected the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA Commissioner-General's submission that the appeal was defective because it failed to identify any of the grounds of appeal prescribed by Article 2(1) of the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT Statute. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant¡¯s ground of appeal was without merit. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Commissioner-General was obliged to calculate the Appellant¡¯s retirement benefits in accordance with the new Staff Rule and did so correctly. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT did not commit any error of fact and law in arriving at its decision. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal and affirmed the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT judgment.
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-906, Omwanda
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal by the Secretary-General. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT exceeded its competence in reviewing Mr Omwanda¡¯s EOD date, as it was not subject to a timely request for management evaluation. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Mr Omwanda knew or ought to have known from his Letter of Appointment the date from which his appointment was effective, that he had been re-employed, not reinstated, and that its terms applied regardless of any period of former service. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was statutorily barred from hearing Mr Omwanda¡¯s application. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT upheld the appeal and vacated the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT judgment.
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-907, Korduru
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the decision to separate the Applicant was arbitrary, discriminatory, constituted an abuse of authority, and was unlawful. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT was not obliged to set an in-lieu compensation amount, as the decision concerned a lateral transfer, not an appointment, promotion, or termination. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT upheld Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT¡¯s finding that Ms. Koduru¡¯s testimony was not compelling enough to serve as a basis for an award of moral damages. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT rejected Ms. Koduru¡¯s request for costs. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT dismissed the appeal and the cross-appeal and affirmed the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT judgment.
Accountability referral: The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-908, Rockcliffe
Ms Rockcliffe filed an application for execution of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT judgment No. 2017-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-807. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the crux of the matter for determination was whether Ms Rockcliffe¡¯s appointment to and her removal from, the Budget Working Group (BWG) in 2018 fell within the scope of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT¡¯s order in the judgment. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that, although Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT had not explicitly addressed the issue of conflict of interest in its judgment, it impliedly rejected it by means of applying the law in force at the time. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that it was egregious that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµJSPF re-submitted that the previous decision not to give Ms Rockcliffe...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-909, Haroun
Noting that the Appellant, the innocent party, lost her employment, her career prospects within the Organisation, and the offending managers remained entrenched in their positions, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that there was a substantial variation or a striking disparity between the award made by Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT and the award that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered ought to have been made. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that, given that an order of reinstatement was unlikely to be implemented, a more generous award was justifiable in the circumstances. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT did not err in law or fact in denying moral damages, as there was no corroborating...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-910, Newland
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered Mr Newland¡¯s application for interpretation of judgment No. 2018-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-820. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that, given that Mr Newland had already been paid Special Post Allowance, Hazard pay, and outstanding interest, the only questions requiring determination were whether he was entitled to payment of Rest and Recuperation (R&R), free tickets, and the relocation grant. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT accepted that there was a degree of uncertainty regarding these questions. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Mr Newland¡¯s claim that he was entitled to the payment of R&R was unsustainable, as it was not an accruable benefit or entitlement. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT...
2019-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-911, El-Arqan
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT committed an error of fact in stating that the OPT Allowance was paid in local currency, which led Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA DT to commit an error of law in stating that Area Staff Circular No. A/04/2014 was applicable. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Area Staff Circular No. A/04/2014 was only applicable to the Jerusalem Allowance and not the OPT Allowance, which was paid in US Dollars. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that such an error of law would be inconsequential if its second line of reasoning, that no rule or policy requires the CAF be applied to the OPT Allowance, was correct. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that there was no rule requiring...