Search
077 (GVA/2024), Phogat
- Appealed
An application for suspension of action can only be entertained under the jurisdiction of the Dispute Tribunal when the challenged contested decision is the subject of an ongoing management evaluation (see Onana 2010-蘑菇视频AT-008, para. 19; Igbinedion 2011-蘑菇视频AT-159, para. 20). In the present case, the Applicant’s management evaluation request was no longer pending. The evidence showed that the Deputy High Commissioner completed the management evaluation on 27 June 2024, and that the Applicant received the outcome of his management evaluation request the same day. Consequently, as the management...
566 (2024), Hakam Mohammad Shahwan
- Appealed
The 蘑菇视频AT noted that the staff member had filed his appeal of the 蘑菇视频RWA DT Judgment on his application for execution before the 蘑菇视频AT Judgment in the underlying case was issued and the Commissioner-General had an opportunity to address the 蘑菇视频AT Judgment before submitting the answer to the present appeal. The 蘑菇视频AT found that given these circumstances, it was in the interest of procedural fairness to allow the staff member to submit additional pleadings 20 days from the issuance of the Order and not exceeding five pages. The 蘑菇视频AT granted the motion for additional pleadings.
蘑菇视频DT/2024/039, Massamba
The Tribunal noted that based on the evidence before it and not contested by the Applicant, the sanction letter was issued on 1 July 2022 and the Applicant received it on 5 July 2022. Pursuant to staff rule 11.2(b), disciplinary decisions are not subject to management evaluation. This meant that the Applicant ought to have filed his application no later than Tuesday, 4 October 2022 to comply with the 90-calendar day deadline. He filed his application on 31 January 2024, which was more than a year after the statutory deadline. Accordingly, the Tribunal found the application not receivable ratio...
蘑菇视频DT/2024/037, Noble
The Tribunal found that the Applicant had not proved that he suffered any direct adverse effect on account of the contested decision. The contested decision is therefore not an administrative decision within the meaning of art. 2(1) of the Dispute Tribunal’s Statute.
蘑菇视频DT/2024/038, Siddique
The main issue for the Tribunal’s consideration in this case related to whether the abolishment of the Applicant’s post leading to the non-renewal of his fixed-term appointment was lawful.
The Tribunal defined the issues to be examined in the present case as follows:
Whether the restructuring was genuine;
The evidence on record showed that the restructuring was done within the framework of the 蘑菇视频 Secretariat-wide transition of Enterprise Information and Communication Technology (“ICT”) services to the cloud. ESCAP made strategic changes to implement this new approach, leading to the...
蘑菇视频DT/2024/036, O'Mullane
The Tribunal noted that, as stipulated in sec. 5.1 of ST/AI/2017/1, “OIOS retains the ultimate authority to decide which cases it will consider and shall determine whether the information of unsatisfactory conduct received merits any action”.
Accordingly, the Tribunal found that the contested decision was lawful.
As the decision by OIOS not to open an investigation was found to be a lawful exercise of the Administration’s discretion, there was no basis for the referral of this case to the Secretary-General for possible action to enforce accountability.
066 (NY/2024), Scepanovic
The Tribunal noted that the Applicant requested the interim measure of “[s]uspension of [a]ction of the proposed separation of the Applicant” under art. 14 of the Rules of Procedure. The applicable rule stipulates that an application for interim measures during the proceedings must not concern appointment, promotion or termination. As this was clearly a case where the application concerned termination, the temporary relief set out in art.14 was unavailable to the Applicant.
In any event, the Tribunal noted that the contested decision had already been implemented and that the Applicant had...
蘑菇视频DT/2024/035, Sellami
The Tribunal finds that the application is not receivable ratione materiae because the Applicant, by his own admission, failed to request management evaluation of the contested decisions.
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1442, Alaa Yasir Al-Bustanji
The 蘑菇视频AT held that the 蘑菇视频RWA DT correctly identified several procedural irregularities in the contested decision. Pursuant to paragraph 9 of the Department of Internal Oversight Services (DIOS) Technical Instruction 02/2016 on 蘑菇视频RWA’s Investigation Policy (DTI 02/2016), the investigation should have been authorized within 10 days of the Intake Committee’s report; yet here, the authorization to investigate took 11 months to be given. The 蘑菇视频AT found that this delay was so excessive that it would distress an average person.
Analyzing the evidence presented by the staff member regarding the...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1441, AAR
The Appeals Tribunal concluded that the 蘑菇视频DT did not err in finding that the Administration had established that AAR had unlawfully disclosed confidential information and had unlawfully failed to disclose a conflict of interest and recuse himself.
The Appeals Tribunal was also satisfied that the administrative measure imposed on AAR was proportionate to his misconduct, and that the 蘑菇视频DT did not commit any error in awarding moral damages for the harm AAR incurred due to the undue delay in completing the disciplinary process.
The Appeals Tribunal therefore dismissed the appeals.
蘑菇视频DT/2024/033, Negasa
The Applicant was given the opportunity to complete his application with the mandatory prerequisite for the filing of an application before the 蘑菇视频DT. He did not.
蘑菇视频DT/2024/034, IK
This case revealed overt sexual harassment where both words and physical touching were used and attempted to extract sexual favour, but even though no such favour was extracted, the harassment caused harm to the victim who was put in fear of loss of her position in the Organization and caused unnecessary tension in the staff relations between the persons involved.
In this case both words and acts were used together during a short period of persistence. When this happens in a work setting it can cause serious emotional stress and hurt. Based on the evidence this is what occurred in this case.
...2024-蘑菇视频AT-1440, Gheorghe Catalin RADU
As a preliminary matter, the Appeals Tribunal found that Mr. Radu had failed to demonstrate exceptional circumstances to support his request for anonymity and accordingly dismissed his request.
The Appeals Board dismissed Mr. Radu’s appeal in relation to Appeals Board Decision No. 1. The Appeals Tribunal found that even if the Staff Rule was to be interpreted as to require consultation with the Medical Clinic at that time, the Organization’s failure to abide by the Staff Rule would not render the decision void ab initio.
Turning to the appeal against Appeals Board Decision No. 2 to...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1439-Corr.1, Egor Ovcharenko
The Appeals Tribunal found that the proportional adjustment of workload standards for self-revision services was a matter that fell squarely within the Administration’s discretionary authority. The Appeals Tribunal was satisfied that the Administration followed all proper procedures when taking and implementing the contested decision, and the 蘑菇视频DT properly determined that there was no requirement for staff management consultations at the departmental or office level in relation to a specific appealable administrative decision.
The Appeals Tribunal dismissed the appeal and affirmed Judgment...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1439, Egor Ovcharenko
The Appeals Tribunal found that the proportional adjustment of workload standards for self-revision services was a matter that fell squarely within the Administration’s discretionary authority. The Appeals Tribunal was satisfied that the Administration followed all proper procedures when taking and implementing the contested decision, and the 蘑菇视频DT properly determined that there was no requirement for staff management consultations at the departmental or office level in relation to a specific appealable administrative decision.
The Appeals Tribunal dismissed the appeal and affirmed Judgment No...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1439-Corr.1, Egor Ovcharenko
The Appeals Tribunal found that the proportional adjustment of workload standards for self-revision services was a matter that fell squarely within the Administration’s discretionary authority. The Appeals Tribunal was satisfied that the Administration followed all proper procedures when taking and implementing the contested decision, and the 蘑菇视频DT properly determined that there was no requirement for staff management consultations at the departmental or office level in relation to a specific appealable administrative decision.
The Appeals Tribunal dismissed the appeal and affirmed Judgment No...
054 (GVA/2024), Applicant
- Appealed
A decision made by the Duty Judge is not constantly open for entertainment until decided by the assigned Judge to a case. That would undermine the role of the Duty Judge and render precarious the principle of legal certainty. The principles of transparency and accountability apply to the entire internal justice system regardless of the facts under dispute, the charges of misconduct or the disciplinary measure applied, unless exceptional circumstances guide the Tribunal differently. Concerning exceptional circumstances, the principle of publicity can only be departed from where the applicant...
蘑菇视频DT/2024/032, Aguilar Valle
Considering the circumstances, the most appropriate remedy would be to rescind the contested decision (in comparison, see the Appeals Tribunal in Lucchini 2021-蘑菇视频AT-1121 and Rolli 2023-蘑菇视频AT-1346).
It is standard practice and courtesy in the Organization that, albeit fixed-term appointments, per definition, do not carry any expectancy of renewal under staff rule 4.13(c), a staff member whose fixed-term appointment is not to be renewed is to receive a pre-notification concerning the non-extension, at least 30 days before its expiry. The Respondent has not argued or submitted any documentation...
蘑菇视频DT/2024/031, Abdelaal
The Tribunal observed that a review of the evidence in this case indicated that the panel’s assessment of the Applicant’s interview was proper. Accordingly, the Tribunal held that the Applicant received full and fair consideration and that the Administration followed all applicable procedures.
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1438, Ann-Christin Raschdorf
The 蘑菇视频AT dismissed the application for revision, finding that none of the alleged new facts were “new facts” for the purpose of Article 11(1) of the 蘑菇视频AT Statute. The alleged new facts either occurred after the issuance of the 蘑菇视频AT Judgment, were known to the Appeals Tribunal, or matters of law.
The 蘑菇视频AT granted the application for correction in part, to the extent that the 蘑菇视频AT agreed with Ms. Raschdorf's argument that an error arose in paragraph 44 of the 蘑菇视频AT Judgment where the 蘑菇视频AT wrongly referred to the Advisory Board on Compensation Claims instead of the Pension Fund.
Finally, the...