Search
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1195, Samer Mohammad
The 蘑菇视频AT decided that mistakes in the way the summary dismissal decision was communicated to the appellant did not affect the fact that the real decision had ultimately been taken by the competent person in the Commissioner-General and not by any delegated authority.
It was undisputed that Mr. Mohammad was not afforded the opportunity to comment on the additional evidence produced against him after the re-opening of the investigation (two interviews of student B’s mother and student B). However, neither in his appeal nor in his initial application to the 蘑菇视频RWA DT did he point out any...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1196, Mohamad Alothman
蘑菇视频AT considered an appeal by Mr. Al Othman against 蘑菇视频RWA Judgment No. 蘑菇视频RWA/DT/2020/073. It also considered a cross-appeal by the Commissioner-General of 蘑菇视频RWA, to the extent that the Judgment awarded Mr. Al Othman compensation.
蘑菇视频AT held that there was clear and convincing evidence established that Mr. Al Othman committed the alleged offences. The 蘑菇视频RWA DT conclusions were accurate, based on evidence on record and common knowledge and 蘑菇视频AT found no reason to differ from them. 蘑菇视频AT shared the 蘑菇视频RWA DT’s view that the only reasonable conclusion available to the trial Judge, resulting from the...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1193, Carolina Larriera
Ms. Larriera sought revision of the 蘑菇视频AT judgment on the grounds that new decisive facts had emerged from the French government regarding her relationship with the deceased participant of the 蘑菇视频JSPF, Mr. M. Specifically, she maintains that the French government has endorsed the findings of a Brazilian court that she was in a “stable union” with Mr. M., and that this has also been annotated on the death certificate of Mr. M.
蘑菇视频AT observed that Ms. Larriera’s application for revision was untimely. In addition, 蘑菇视频AT concluded that these allegedly decisive facts occurred in 2021, well after the...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1192, Andrew Webster
蘑菇视频AT considered an appeal by Mr. Webster. 蘑菇视频AT held that although the current legal framework (ISA Staff Rule 11.2), mentions the establishment of a neutral first instance process with staff participation to take a decision upon any appeal by staff members against an administrative decision alleging the non-observance of their terms of appointment, including all pertinent regulations and rules, there is, to this date, no such neutral first instance process. According to the Staff Rules, the JAB Panel shall submit a report to the Secretary-General, who takes the final decision.
While it is...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/036, TESFAYE
The Tribunal agreed with the Respondent that the Applicant was reckless in his failure to report a fraud which he was aware of. He chose to conceal and abet the perpetration of a fraud. The facts were established to the requisite standard by the Applicant’s own admissions and the evidence on record. The Tribunal held that the established facts clearly constituted misconduct as charged. The elements of the charge of abetting and concealing fraud were established through the evidence. The Applicant who had possession of important knowledge about fraudulent document passing through his office...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/035, Mancinelli
The Tribunal held that the Applicant had an obligation as a staff member to uphold the highest standards of integrity which include acting with honesty. In her submissions, she argued that she acted truthfully and with honesty. She gave reasons why she thought she could use Organization’s assets for personal benefit. The Tribunal found that the Applicant’s justifications were not supported by any rule or regulation. She acted dishonestly in breach of integrity standards by using the Organization’s UPS facility for personal benefit without any lawful justification. The Tribunal found that the...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/034, Kiriella
Receivability ratione materiae. The Applicant’s management evaluation request was not clear on whether he was making allegations of misconduct against his Supervisor, which would need to be dutifully investigated, or citing performance or management issues to be addressed by management. Similarly, the Applicant did not provide any evidence that the matter of lawfulness of the decision to place him on ALWP was ever formally contested by him. Hence, any determination against the decision not to further investigate the Applicant’s complaints of harassment against his supervisor or against his...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/033, Chernov
In Judgment No. 蘑菇视频DT/2022/028, the Tribunal rejected the application in Case No. 蘑菇视频DT/NY/2021/023, finding that the Applicant is ineligible for boarding allowance for his child. In this case, the Applicant essentially challenges the same decision to find him ineligible for boarding allowance for his child, the issue of which was already resolved in Judgment No. 蘑菇视频DT/2022/028. Therefore, under the doctrine of res judicata, the Tribunal rejects the present application.
蘑菇视频DT/2022/032, Kavosh
The rationale for imposing such an extraordinary administrative measure in matters of ALWOP concerning sexual misconduct is twofold, firstly to act as a deterrent for staff members from engaging in sexual exploitation and abuse and secondly, to protect the interests of the Organization by upholding its integrity and reputation. Any decision to extend ALWOP must be reasonable and proportionate. A decision to extend ALWOP is a drastic administrative measure and normally should be of short duration. In determining whether an extension of ALWOP is lawful, the Tribunal shall be guided by factors...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/031, Ross
At the time of the contested decision to not investigate his complaint of harassment and abuse of authority into his separation from service and alleged blacklisting, the Applicant had been separated from service for more than four and a half years and was no longer a staff member in the strict sense. Therefore, for the application to be receivable, the contested decision must have a bearing on the Applicant’s status as a former staff member in the sense that it affects his previous contractual rights. In determining whether the contested decision affects the Applicant’s previous contractual...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/030, Applicant
The case was decided by a bench of three judges. The Majority decided to dismiss the application with one Judge dissenting. On whether the facts of the case were established, the Majority concluded that the Respondent had substantiated with clear and convincing evidence the factual basis of the contested decision. Regarding misconduct, the Majority concurred that the act of forcing sexual intercourse, by the Applicant on the Complainant-(i.e., rape), amounted to sexual abuse in a grave form and, as such, constituted a serious misconduct prescribed by staff regulation 10.1(b) and staff rule 1.2...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/029, Ponce Gonzalez
The Tribunal is satisfied that the evidence supports the Hiring Manager’s evaluation of the selected candidate’s candidacy. Based on the evidence, the Tribunal finds that it was within the Respondent’s discretion to select the successful candidate. Moreover, the Tribunal is not persuaded that the Applicant has shown that he had a significant chance of selection over the selected candidate, absent any of the procedural irregularities that he alleges.
蘑菇视频DT/2022/027, Kashkinbekov
Whether the Administration provided a valid and fair reason for the contested decision In determining whether a valid and fair reason exists to terminate the Applicant’s appointment for unsatisfactory performance, the Tribunal will examine in turn the following issues: i. Whether the Applicant in fact failed to meet the performance standards; ii. Whether he was aware, or could reasonably be expected to have been aware, of the required standards; iii. Whether he was given a fair opportunity to meet the required standards; and iv. Whether termination of appointment is an appropriate action for...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/028, Chernov
In this case, the Administration initially decided that the Applicant was eligible for a prorated amount of lump-sum boarding allowance, but during the management evaluation process, the Administration found the previous decision erroneous and decided that the Applicant was in fact not entitled to any boarding allowance. Therefore, the decision subject to judicial review in this case is the Administration’s decision to find him ineligible for any boarding allowance. It is clear that under staff regulation 3.2 and Appendix B to the Staff Regulations and Rules, eligible staff members are only...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1210, Appellant
蘑菇视频AT held that the 蘑菇视频DT erred both in not permitting the Appellant to call a witness (AA) and in the incorrect conclusions it drew from her hearsay evidence. 蘑菇视频AT held that, to the extent that BB (a non-蘑菇视频 staff member) was a witness adverse to the Appellant, the failure of the Secretary-General to secure her attendance before the 蘑菇视频DT permitted an adverse inference which detracted considerably from the credibility and reliability of her allegations in the OIOS investigation report. 蘑菇视频AT held that little weight could be attached to the evidence of two unidentified 蘑菇视频 staff members, to whom the...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1209, Edoardo Gianotti
蘑菇视频AT held the 蘑菇视频DT was correct to find the application non-receivable ratione materiae. At the time of the 蘑菇视频DT Judgment, there was no final administrative decision that had direct legal consequences on the Appellant’s terms of employment. In addition, in the intervening time, the Appellant has been selected for the post, and therefore, he has received that which he had sought originally, making his request for rescission of the contested decision moot. Regarding the request for compensation for the pay differential for 17 months, the Tribunal found because there was no appealable...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1208, Hatim Sobier
蘑菇视频AT first explained that this is a case where the 蘑菇视频DT should have held a hearing to determine the states of mind of those persons who decided that the Staff Member should not have been placed on the roster. The Tribunal defined bias as follows: (paras. 29 - 32) "29. Bias is an element of natural justice which examines not only the mind of the decision?maker subjectively, but the manifestation of the process of decision-making examined objectively. Put another way, a decision is not only biased if made by a decision?maker deliberately intending to favour or disadvantage the subject of it for...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1207, Michelle Rockcliffe
蘑菇视频AT disagreed and found the background of the prior retaliation against the Staff Member affects the principle of the presumption of regularity. In light of the circumstances of this particular case, 蘑菇视频AT found the Administration bore the obligation to justify the lawfulness of its decision to cancel the Job Opening. 蘑菇视频AT thus found the 蘑菇视频DT erred by not requiring the Administration to establish its justification in law for the cancellation of the Job Opening. The administrative decision to cancel the Job Opening was rescinded, and the Tribunal set in lieu compensation at two years’ net base...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1205, Roger Kuate
Mr. Kuate appealed. 蘑菇视频AT dismissed Mr. Kuate's contention that there was no basis until 1 April 2019, date of the final divorce decision, for the recovery of the allowances on grounds that the Cameroonian judgments were not final until that date. 蘑菇视频AT found that Order No. 791 contained an enforceability clause and therefore the measures provided in that order went into force with immediate effect. Consequently, Mr. Kuate and his wife legally separated on 26 November 2015 when the order was issued. Also, on the basis of this order, from this day on Mr. Kuate had legal custody for (only) two of...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1204, null Secretary-General
The Secretary-General filed an appeal. 蘑菇视频AT granted the appeal and vacated the 蘑菇视频DT Judgment. 蘑菇视频AT held that while the determination of which staff members should be compared is “primarily guided by the functional title as per the staff member’s letter of appointment”, there can be cases where the functional title does not reflect the actual functions performed as in the present case. In these circumstances, the CHRO must determine which individual falls into which occupational group. Ms. Barud’s role and functions changed in May 2018 to a Facilities Management Assistant. Therefore, at the...