Search
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1450, Mohammad Hossain
The 蘑菇视频AT specified that the sole issue was whether the applicant, a former staff member, had presented a new and decisive fact that was unknown to him and the Appeals Tribunal when the prior 蘑菇视频AT Judgment was decided, and that this fact would have materially impacted the outcome of that Judgment.
The 蘑菇视频AT reviewed the documents submitted by the former staff member and concluded that they were all known to him prior to the issuance of the 蘑菇视频AT Judgment. The former staff member essentially repeated or added to the same arguments he made in his original appeal, and the 蘑菇视频AT had already...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1453, Timothy Kennedy
The 蘑菇视频AT held that the Administration provided a thorough and detailed analysis of the factors required to be considered in the disciplinary context. This included : the past practice of the Organization in comparable matters, the seriousness of the misconduct; whether the conduct was accidental, careless, reckless, or deliberate; whether the staff member followed procedures and was self-aware of the conduct; whether, given the staff member’s experience, the misconduct was minor, substantive, or severe; the risk of damage to the Organization and staff; as well as any mitigating factors.
The...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1452, Ousmane Tamba Dia
The 蘑菇视频AT held that the 蘑菇视频DT did not commit any error in procedure that affected the outcome of the case by partially denying the former staff member’s motions for production of additional evidence or by not granting him sufficient additional time to respond to the Secretary-General’s submissions.
The 蘑菇视频AT also concluded that the 蘑菇视频DT appropriately identified the contested decision as the 1 April 2022 decision finding him ineligible to participate in ASHI. The 蘑菇视频AT observed that the former staff member himself identified this decision in both his 蘑菇视频DT application and his management evaluation...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1449, Michael David Antoine
The 蘑菇视频AT noted that the staff member publicly engaged in acts of a sexual nature in a clearly marked United Nations vehicle, bringing disrepute to the Organization and difficulties with the host country.
The 蘑菇视频AT found that the case was not one where the issues required the 蘑菇视频DT’s determination of the credibility of contradicting testimonies of parties or witnesses and the lack of a 蘑菇视频DT hearing had not affected its decision. The 蘑菇视频DT had before it a video clip depicting the actions in question, which were clearly of a sexual nature.
The 蘑菇视频AT agreed with the 蘑菇视频DT that the lawfulness of the...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1448, Ray Steven Millan
The 蘑菇视频AT noted that the staff member allowed an unauthorized female individual to board a United Nations vehicle assigned to him and to publicly commit acts of a sexual nature in the rear seat, bringing disrepute to the Organization and difficulties with the host country.
The 蘑菇视频AT found that the case was not one where the issues required the 蘑菇视频DT’s determination of the credibility of contradicting testimonies of parties or witnesses and the lack of a 蘑菇视频DT hearing had not affected its decision. The 蘑菇视频DT appropriately considered the former staff member's admissions, as well as the video clip...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1451-Corr.1, Cevat Ozturk
The 蘑菇视频AT held that the administrative decision concerning reimbursements to the staff member took effect in law on 7 May 2019, when he received the wire transfer from the Organization. The reasons for this reimbursement amount were discussed with him shortly before the wire transfer was made. Although explanations of the underlying calculations were repeated in subsequent email exchanges with the staff member, those repetitions were not additional or new administrative decisions that were open to challenge by the staff member, thereby resetting the statute of limitations.
The 蘑菇视频AT found...
086 (NY/2024), Sinha
The Tribunal ordered the parties to produce consolidated lists of agreed and disputed facts to enable it understand the factual issues at stake.
The Tribunal also ordered the parties to indicate what additional documentaton they requested to be disclosed, and the identities of any witnesses they wished to call, specifying what disputed facts the witnesses would testify about.
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1447, Iyofe Christine Isasi
The 蘑菇视频AT held that Mr. Kankwenda, a late participant in the 蘑菇视频JSPF, married another individual, Ms. M.T., in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) in 1971. This fact, which Ms. Isasi herself did not contest, was supported by a marriage certificate and was consistent with the information regarding the dates of birth of Mr. Kankwenda’s children and the identities of their mothers. The 蘑菇视频AT highlighted that Ms. Isasi admitted that the two marriage certificates she submitted after Mr. Kankwenda’s death, purportedly showing their marriage on 17 January 1971, were falsified, undermining her...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1446, Ashok Kumar Nigam
The 蘑菇视频AT held that, since Mr. Nigam based his interlocutory appeal on alleged errors of fact and law by the 蘑菇视频DT Judge President, with no allegation of the 蘑菇视频DT acting extra-jurisdictionally or similarly in excess of its jurisdiction, he must wait to exercise his right of appeal until a final decision has been made.
The 蘑菇视频AT concluded that an earlier 蘑菇视频DT Judgment contained neither any indication of bias by Judge Belle against Mr. Nigam, nor any criticism beyond what a reasonably informed observer might expect from a partly erroneous judgment and its subsequent appellate review.
The 蘑菇视频AT...
570 (2024), Abdurrahman Turk
- Appealed
The 蘑菇视频AT found that the Secretary-General’s request that it suspend the time limit for filing the answer until the motion for summary judgment was decided was moot because the Secretary-General had already filed the answer. The 蘑菇视频AT observed that the timing of the Secretary-General’s request for a suspension of the time limit had been most impractical as the staff member would not have the opportunity to comment on the motion for summary judgment. The 蘑菇视频AT nonetheless found that, given that the pleadings were complete, it was most practicable to decide this appeal during its regular session as...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1445, Moner Ahmed Nasser
The 蘑菇视频AT held that the staff member’s application for revision failed to meet the statutory requirements outlined in Article 11(1) of the 蘑菇视频AT Statute. It found that the facts raised by the staff member were not unknown to him before the issuance of the 蘑菇视频AT Judgment and, in any event, would not have changed the outcome of the case, which was found to be not receivable. The 蘑菇视频AT further held that the staff member’s arguments were irrelevant and reiterated those he previously advanced before the 蘑菇视频AT.
The 蘑菇视频AT dismissed the application for revision.
Accountability Referral: The 蘑菇视频AT noted...
568 (2024), Ivan Aguilar Valle
- Appealed
The 蘑菇视频AT found that the present motion was distinguishable from a typical motion for withdrawal of an appeal: the non-moving party objects to the withdrawal as a revised appeal would enable the Secretary-General to address arguments included in the answer and, second, the Secretary-General still deems it necessary to pursue an appeal. The 蘑菇视频AT held that its reiteration in a recent case that appeals on the merits and relief should be considered together had not been new and was an insufficient basis on which to request the filing of a revised appeal. The 蘑菇视频AT found, however, that when the 蘑菇视频DT...
蘑菇视频DT/2024/043, Santambrogio
Receivability
The Tribunal found that to the extent the Applicant challenged the legal framework of 蘑菇视频HCR, and requested the removal of a part of para. 34 of the Recruitment and Assignments Policy, her application was not receivable ratione materiae. The application was only receivable concerning the decision not to select the Applicant for the G-7 position of Senior Resource Management Associate, Addressing SEA and SH.
Merits
Whether the applicable procedures were properly followed
First, the Tribunal addressed the Applicant’s argument concerning the alleged forgery of the document...
蘑菇视频DT/2024/041, Dhindsa
The Tribunal noted that Order No. 20 (NBI/2024) in Case No. 蘑菇视频DT/NBI/2024/008 rejected the Applicant's application for suspension of action under art. 13 of the 蘑菇视频DT Rules of Procedure. The Applicant maintained that the Tribunal misconstrued his application in Case No. 蘑菇视频DT/NBI/2024/008 as being filed under art. 13 of the 蘑菇视频DT Rules of Procedure (governing suspension of action during a management evaluation), rather than art. 14 (governing suspension of action during the proceedings) of those Rules.
The Tribunal held that to the extent that the Applicant’s intent was to file an application...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1444, Yelena Goldenberg
The 蘑菇视频AT held that the Administration did not act unreasonably or unlawfully in requiring the staff member to work from the office two days per week. It further held that relevant considerations, including the staff member’s personal and medical circumstances, were taken into consideration, and irrelevant considerations were excluded. The 蘑菇视频AT also found that there was no obligation on the Administration to establish that the requested accommodations represented a disproportionate or undue burden on the workplace.
The 蘑菇视频AT also found no merit in the staff member’s argument that the lack of...
2024-蘑菇视频AT-1443, Ahmad Shukri Safi
The 蘑菇视频AT held that Mr. Safi failed to discharge his burden in identifying in what respect and for what reasons the 蘑菇视频RWA DT erred in its Judgment. Mr. Safi merely reiterated the same arguments that he had presented in his application to the 蘑菇视频RWA DT. The 蘑菇视频AT stated that it is not its role to reexamine the staff member’s case anew, and accordingly, his appeal must fail. The 蘑菇视频AT also observed that the 蘑菇视频RWA DT drew reasonable inferences from its extensive fact-finding exercise and delivered a well-reasoned judgment.
The appeal was dismissed, and Judgment No. 蘑菇视频RWA/DT/2023/011 was...
蘑菇视频DT/2024/042, N’Dao
It is not in dispute that the Applicant received notice of the contested decision on 8 May 2023 and that he only sought management evaluation in respect of the contested decision on 2 May 2024, approximately one year later. Since the management evaluation request was submitted outside of the statutory 60-day deadline stipulated in staff rule 11.2(c), the application is non-receivable ratione materiae (see, also, Christensen 2013-蘑菇视频AT-335).
The Respondent’s motion for summary judgment was granted.
080 (GVA/2024), Jane Wambugu
- Appealed
As indicated by the Respondent in his reply, the selected candidate signed the letter of appointment and assumed her functions on 19 June 2024. She further completed the onboarding formalities on 24 June 2024. Consequently, the Tribunal finds that it can no longer entertain the instant application, which was filed on 28 June 2024, thus after the contested decision has been implemented. Granting an injunction would require reversing the onboarding of the selected candidate, which it clearly cannot do.
蘑菇视频DT/2024/040, Suarez Liste
The dispute between the parties relates to whether the Applicant met the condition of satisfactory service during his probationary period to warrant a contractual right to have his FTA converted into a CA. In this context, the Applicant claims that his FRO and SRO did not identify any performance shortcomings during the performance cycle, including at the two “landmark” performance discussions they had previously to the contested decision. Allegedly, the first time he heard about any dissatisfaction with his performance was when he was informed that he would not receive a CA and, instead...
074 (GVA/2024), Nicholas O'Regan
- Appealed
Since the management evaluation in this case has been completed, one of the cumulative and mandatory conditions specified in art. 2.2 of the Tribunal’s Statute is not fulfilled. The Tribunal will therefore not examine if the remaining statutory requirements have been met, as the matter now lies moot.