Search
蘑菇视频DT/2022/078, Yodjeu Ntemde
The Tribunal finds that the Applicant does not meet the criteria which would entitle him to seek recourse within the internal justice system. From the documents before the Tribunal follows that the Applicant is not a United Nations staff member. The Applicant’s submissions do not establish that an offer of employment had been issued and the Applicant does not provide any evidence that he is entitled to contract-based rights with a view to employment as a staff member within the Organization. The Administration did not undertake to conclude a contract for the recruitment of the Applicant as a...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/077, Suarez Liste
In asserting whether the Administration properly determined the Applicant’s step-in-grade, the core issue before the Tribunal is whether and, if so, to what extent, the Applicant’s Ph.D. experience in Economics would constitute relevant work experience for a language professional under the Grading Guidelines for language staff.
The documentary evidence on record shows that the Applicant did his Ph.D. in Economics from 1 October 2014 to 9 June 2019 on a full-time basis. Therefore, his Ph.D. experience in Economics would amount to around two years and four months of relevant experience...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1267, AAD
The Appeals Tribunal rejected AAD's request for an oral hearing because she provided no persuasive reasons in support of her request.
蘑菇视频AT held that the Dispute Tribunal erred in determining whether the established facts qualify as misconduct and whether the disciplinary sanctions were proportionate. In its Judgment, the Dispute Tribunal also erred by substituting its determination of the appropriate disciplinary sanction for that of the Administration and, as such, the 蘑菇视频AT concluded that the 蘑菇视频DT Judgment must be vacated. AAD said her actions did not amount to misconduct and sought a...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/076, Guenfoudi
The scope of judicial review in termination cases due to unsatisfactory service is limited to reviewing whether the appointment was lawfully terminated based on the applicable rules. It is not the role of the Tribunal to conduct a review of the performance evaluation process or to determine a different performance rating. In this case, the Applicant was notified that based on the 2020-2021 overall rating of “does not meet performance expectations” and the 2019-2020 “partially meets performance expectations”, the Administration decided to terminate his continuing appointment. Having examined...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1269, Ashok Kumar Nigam
蘑菇视频AT held that the 蘑菇视频DT Judgment was inconsistent in finding parts of the application irreceivable but not addressing what was to happen to the balance of the claim which was receivable. 蘑菇视频AT held that to the extent that the 蘑菇视频DT held that some of the Appellant’s claims were not receivable as they were not filed within time after management evaluation, 蘑菇视频DT did not err in fact or law and 蘑菇视频AT upheld such conclusions. 蘑菇视频AT held that there were errors by 蘑菇视频DT in respect of which the appeal had to be allowed, which were: (1) the 蘑菇视频DT decision not to receive the application in respect of claims...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1263, AAB
蘑菇视频AT dismissed the appeal. As a preliminary matter, 蘑菇视频AT denied AAB's request for an oral hearing on grounds that there was no need for further clarification since the factual and legal issues arising from the appeal had already been clearly defined by the parties, and an oral hearing would not assist in the expeditious and fair disposal of the case. 蘑菇视频AT dismissed AAB's claim that her right to a fair trial before the 蘑菇视频DT had been violated because, since the application was found not to be receivable, and she was denied the opportunity to file a rejoinder. 蘑菇视频AT noted that there is no...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1268, Leila Gharagozloo Pakkala
Ms. Pakkala filed an appeal. 蘑菇视频AT found that the decision to impose the administrative measures on Ms. Pakkala was a lawful and reasonable exercise of discretion.
The letter of the Director, DHR clearly set out the rationale for imposing the administrative measures, i.e. that the investigative process had surfaced a pattern of behavior exhibited by Ms. Pakkala over time which was cause for concern and justified the administrative measures. While the Director, DHR found the evidence of alleged harassment was not clear and convincing, in her opinion there were reasonable grounds to believe...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1266, Korkut Yavuz
The only issue on appeal is whether the 蘑菇视频DT judgment’s orders on in-lieu compensation and compensation for moral harm are free of error. In the present case, the 蘑菇视频DT took into account the specific circumstances of the case, in particular the seniority of Mr. Yavuz, the type of appointment held, and the chance of renewal of the appointment in a position still required by the Administration and set an in-lieu compensation of three months. Mr. Yavuz complains that the 蘑菇视频DT should also have considered the nature of the irregularity and the seriousness of the breaches of his rights and the...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1265, Faraj El-Awar
The 蘑菇视频DT found the non-renewal decision unlawful because the Secretary-General did not show that it was motivated by a lack of funds. Although the 蘑菇视频DT committed several errors of law, its main finding is not put into doubt by the Secretary-General’s appeal. Therefore, in this respect, the Secretary-General’s appeal cannot succeed. 蘑菇视频DT's finding that 蘑菇视频-Habitat silently accepted Mr. El-Awar's condition of reassignment is erroneous. A reassignment is an administrative decision, a unilateral act imposed on the staff member by the Administration. It is not a contract which can be bargained or...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1264, AAC
The essential question for determination on appeal is whether the 蘑菇视频DT correctly held that the alleged misconduct of creating a hostile work environment and giving of gifts was proved in accordance with the standard of clear and convincing evidence. In other words, did the evidence establish the alleged misconduct to a high degree of probability? At its essence, therefore, this case involves strongly contested disputes of fact about whether AAC conducted himself in a manner that was abusive and created a hostile working environment. The Administration says he did. AAC strongly denies it. Thus...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/075, Stepanovic
Where a staff member is challenging many different administrative decisions to be considered as a whole,with cumulative effect, there is no need to challenge them (by a management evaluation request and then application before the Tribunal) one by one.
The Applicant alleged that he was deprived of his core functions in 2018 and 2019, that is more than two years before the application. He only requested management evaluation in April 2021 against a 2018 decision, and not towards the subsequent administrative decisions.
Even if the Tribunal accepted that the last of the adverse decisions was...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1261, Appellant
蘑菇视频AT rejected Mr. Valme’s claim that the allegation of sexual exploitation and abuse had not been established against him, on grounds that any consideration about the complaint of sexual abuse was beyond the scope of the case, because his application concerned other prohibited conduct that came to light during the investigation. 蘑菇视频AT found no merit in Mr. Valme’s contention that the 蘑菇视频DT failed to consider the totality of the evidence and referred to it in a selective way, thereby displaying bias. 蘑菇视频AT found that it was inherent to the principle of judicial persuasion that courts and...
蘑菇视频DT/2022/074, Duparc
There are incidents on which the Applicant had no direct knowledge. Consequently, he has no standing in filing a complaint of prohibited conduct in relation to them.
It was inappropriate for the Director, DA, 蘑菇视频OG, to play an instrumental role in the constitution of the investigation panel considering that he was the decision-maker in relation to one alleged incident, was a material witness in the investigation and was highly likely to be interviewed by the investigation panel. Several factors cumulatively gave rise to a reasonable perception of a conflict of interest on the part of a panel...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1262, Egor Ovcharenko et al., Danield Edward Kutner et al.
As a preliminary matter, 蘑菇视频AT dismissed the appeals of two staff members who were not a party to the proceedings before the 蘑菇视频DT and had no standing. On the merits, 蘑菇视频AT held that there was a reviewable administrative decision within the meaning of Article 2(1)(a) of the 蘑菇视频DT Statute. 蘑菇视频AT held that the 蘑菇视频DT erred finding that the announcement by the USG/DGACM dated 8 April 2021 that the daily workload of translators would be increased to 5.8 pages and of self-revisers to 6.4 pages, was not an appealable administrative decision for the purpose of Article 2(1) of the 蘑菇视频DT Statute. 蘑菇视频AT held...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1260, Jules Yatte Beda
Mr. Beda appealed. As a preliminary matter, 蘑菇视频AT dismissed Mr. Beda's motion seeking leave to file a rejoinder on grounds that there was no probative value to the rejoinder Mr. Beda sought to file, and there was nothing new in the Administration's answer that would require him to have an opportunity to provide a rebuttal or rejoinder. Turning to the merits, 蘑菇视频AT found that the 蘑菇视频DT had applied the correct legal standard in its Judgment - whether the facts had been established by clear and convincing evidence - and properly assessed the evidence and credibility of witness testimony, making the...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1259, Maguy Bamba
蘑菇视频AT held that the Appellant merely repeated arguments raised before 蘑菇视频DT regarding the evidence. 蘑菇视频AT accepted 蘑菇视频DT’s finding that there was clear and convincing evidence to establish the facts underlying the allegations of misconduct. 蘑菇视频AT held that 蘑菇视频DT applied the appropriate legal standard, namely clear and convincing evidence. 蘑菇视频AT held that 蘑菇视频DT heard the evidence of the complainant, other material witnesses, assessed the credibility and reliability of the testimony under oath before it, determined the probable facts and then rendered a decision as to whether the onus to establish the...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1258, Yulia Andreeva
蘑菇视频AT held that an analysis of the e-mail and other correspondence between 蘑菇视频DP and the Appellant indicated that she could not have been led to believe that her home leave request for January 2020 would be granted. She had been advised that a staff member was entitled to home leave only if the staff member’s contract was anticipated to continue for more than six months after the return from home leave, yet Appellant’s continuing engagement with 蘑菇视频DP was unknown, and her current contract end date was June 30, 2020. 蘑菇视频AT held that 蘑菇视频DP complied with its obligations to consider and decide the...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1257, Alex Lucchini
Mr. Lucchini and the Secretary-General disagreed on whether 蘑菇视频AT confirmed the 蘑菇视频DT’s award of compensation for moral damages, in addition to increasing the amount of in lieu compensation from 10 months to 24 months, or ordered payment of the increased amount of compensation in lieu (of two years’ net base salary) but did not include the original award of compensation for moral harm that had been ordered by the 蘑菇视频DT. Mr. Lucchini filed an application for interpretation seeking confirmation of his view that 蘑菇视频AT’s ruling increased the amount of in lieu compensation from 10 to 24 months’ net...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1253, Cecile Berthaud
The Appeals Tribunal’s first finding is that the 蘑菇视频DT was correct in its holding that Section 17(d) of the Repatriation Policy is not in conflict with Staff Rule 3.19 (g) and, thus, the two sets of provisions fall to be read together coherently.
We also find correct the 蘑菇视频DT’s reasoning that the application of Section 17(d) of the 蘑菇视频DP Repatriation Policy is not limited to 蘑菇视频DP staff members as it seeks to reconcile payments made to staff members within the United Nations system, irrespectively of the fact that the spouse is a 蘑菇视频DP staff member too or not, avoiding in any case to duplicate...
2022-蘑菇视频AT-1256, Gonzalo Ramos
蘑菇视频AT considered an appeal by Mr. Ramos. 蘑菇视频AT held that in order for conduct to constitute sexual harassment, apart from an “unwelcome sexual advance”, it is required that the behavior in question “might reasonably be expected or be perceived to cause offence or humiliation to another, when such conduct interferes with work, […] or creates an intimidating, hostile or offensive work environment” and that “[w]hile typically involving a pattern of behaviour, it can take the form of a single incident”. 蘑菇视频AT was satisfied that there was clear and convincing evidence that the Mr. Ramos’ conduct as...