Search
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-201, Obdeijn
The Appellant contested the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT finding that he was afforded full and fair consideration for the position of Chief and argued that he suffered unfair and discriminatory treatment. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that if the Administration does not comply with a Tribunal¡¯s order to disclose the reasons for an administrative decision, as such, the Tribunal cannot automatically conclude that the decision was arbitrary, but it is entitled to draw an adverse inference from the refusal. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT affirmed the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT finding that the Administration¡¯s decision must be deemed unlawful, as the Secretary-General refused to comply...
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-190, Bekele
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered an appeal limited to the claim that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT ordered inadequate compensation for the losses he sustained as a result of various acts and omissions on the part of the Administration. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT found that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT took due regard for the arguments the Appellant brought in his appeal and that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT, having regarded the parameters of what it could compensate the Appellant for, made adequate provisions for the Appellant¡¯s economic and social losses in its overall award to him. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal and upheld the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT judgment.
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-191, Muratore
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that only circumstances beyond an applicant¡¯s control that prevented them from timely exercising the right of appeal may be considered ¡°exceptional circumstances,¡± justifying a waiver of the statutory time limit. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that an applicant¡¯s initial mistaken belief that decisions were lawful cannot be deemed to constitute exceptional circumstances justifying a waiver of the time limit to appeal those decisions, especially when they had every means of obtaining information from the Administration. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT was not persuaded by the Appellant¡¯s arguments upon appeal and did not find any...
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-192, Akyeampong
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered appeals from both the Secretary-General and M Akyeampong on the issue of whether Ms Akyeampong could be denied a promotion on account of the two reprimands. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the two reprimands had not been an obstacle to Ms Akyeampong filling a D-1 position or being recommended for a promotion. Moreover, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the presence of the two reprimands had not debarred her from being promoted during the 2009 annual promotion session. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT allowed Ms Akyeampong¡¯s appeal in part, rescinded the impugned decision and dismissed the Secretary-General¡¯s appeal, with Judge Weinberg de...
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-193, Al Sayyed
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered Mr Al Sayyed¡¯s appeal and found that the decision to terminate his service, effective from close of business 15 December 2007, and as communicated to him on 30 November 2007, was superseded by the action he took on 4 December 2007, an action reinforced by him on 7 January 2008. Under these circumstances, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµRWA did not err in dismissing Mr Al Sayyed¡¯s appeal against his termination on the basis that there was no termination decision capable of review. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal.
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-194, Kamunyi
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered Mr Kamynyi¡¯s appeal and the Secretary-General¡¯s cross-appeal. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT rejected Mr Kamunyi¡¯s appeal in its entirety and held that it is within the Administration¡¯s discretion to reassign a staff member to a different post at the same level and that such a reassignment is lawful if it is reasonable in the particular circumstances of each case and if it causes no economic prejudice to the staff member. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT rightfully rejected Mr Kamunyi¡¯s request for legal costs, noting that no legal costs were owed to a party when the opposing party had not abused the process. With...
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-195, Shahatit
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered the Appellant¡¯s appeal. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT noted that the established facts showed that the Appellant¡¯s negligence as Head Storekeeper facilitated the misconduct of other staff members and his negligence was evidenced by the excess of merchandise in the storeroom under his control, and by his failure to keep an inventory of the items in his custody. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant neither successfully rebutted these facts, nor demonstrated any flaws in the administrative and disciplinary procedures. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the sanction of demotion was lawful. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT dismissed the appeal and affirmed the...
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-196, Odio-Benito
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant¡¯s application was submitted to Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT after the expiration of the response period; the response period began on the date on which she received a letter from the Management Evaluation Unit informing her that her request for a management evaluation was not receivable because, as a judge, she was not a staff member or a former staff member within the meaning of the Staff Rules. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant¡¯s claims that the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT judge erred on a question of fact, by considering the letter as the decision that concluded the management evaluation, and that it erred on a...
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-197, Ndjadi
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that the Appellant had neither standing to challenge a decision which he alleged did not comply with the stipulations of his service contract nor the right to request the implementation of an arbitration procedure before Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT. However, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT held that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT had committed an error in concluding that the Appellant had manifestly abused the process. The appeal was partially upheld and the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT judgment partially vacated regarding the payment of USD 500.00 for abuse of procedure.
2012-Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT-189, Onogi, et al.
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT considered Mr Elguindi, Ms Onogi and Ms Sheryda¡¯s separate appeals. With respect to Mr Elguindi¡¯s claim, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT did not find that the manner in which Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµJSPF apportioned his monthly pension sum to be unreasonable, capricious or an abuse of discretion. With respect to Ms Onogi¡¯s claim of procedural defects, Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT was not persuaded that there were procedural flaws on the part of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµJSPF such as to render the exercise of its discretion unreasonable or unlawful. Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµAT also did not find merit in Mr Elguindi¡¯s claim of ¡°double-dipping¡± in his opposition to Ms Onogi¡¯s claim for relief from Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµJSPF...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/035, Castillo Cabrera
The Applicant submitted that she has a legitimate expectation of renewal and that the decision not to renew her contract was motivated by extraneous considerations. The Respondent submitted that the decision was taken as a result of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµMIT¡¯s downsizing in view of its eventual closure. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT found that the requirement of urgency was satisfied. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT found that the requirement of prima facie unlawfulness was also satisfied as the reason provided by the Respondent in support of the contested decision appeared to be unsupported by the facts and the documents in this case. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT also found...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/034, Perelli
Outcome: The application was rejected. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT made the following findings: The preliminary fact-finding investigation was initiated properly, but was flawed, because the Applicant was not re-interviewed or given the opportunity to answer the allegations of sexual harassment in writing after the full scope of allegations became known to the investigation panel. However, these flaws did not vitiate the contested decision as they were cured in the process that followed. The findings of the fact-finding investigation report and the accompanying documents justified the decision to initiate formal...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/014, Albert
The Tribunal found that the contested requirement was not inconsistent with the intent of the General Assembly in its resolutions 37/126 and 51/226 and that it fell within the High Commissioner¡¯s discretion to introduce this requirement in view of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµHCR operational realities. Whereas exceptions were made to the contested requirement for medical reasons based on the provisions of the Procedural guidelines for appointments, postings and promotions, the Applicants were not in the same situation as the staff members who were granted such exceptions and therefore they cannot claim that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµHCR did...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/013, Amer
The Tribunal found that the contested requirement was not inconsistent with the intent of the General Assembly in its resolutions 37/126 and 51/226 and that it fell within the High Commissioner¡¯s discretion to introduce this requirement in view of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµHCR operational realities. Whereas exceptions were made to the contested requirement for medical reasons based on the provisions of the Procedural guidelines for appointments, postings and promotions, the Applicants were not in the same situation as the staff members who were granted such exceptions and therefore they cannot claim that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµHCR did...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/012, Maulfair
The Tribunal found that the contested requirement was not inconsistent with the intent of the General Assembly in its resolutions 37/126 and 51/226 and that it fell within the High Commissioner¡¯s discretion to introduce this requirement in view of Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµHCR operational realities. Whereas exceptions were made to the contested requirement for medical reasons based on the provisions of the Procedural guidelines for appointments, postings and promotions, the Applicants were not in the same situation as the staff members who were granted such exceptions and therefore they cannot claim that Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµHCR did...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/033, Rockcliffe
Outcome: Judgment for the Applicant. The parties were ordered to attempt to resolve the issue of appropriate relief, failing which it would be considered by the Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT found that the requirement to take a break in service was unlawful and did not reflect the true facts as no actual break in service or separation took place. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT found that there was no legal requirement for the Applicant to be placed on appointment of limited duration between 5 and 30 June 2009, and the decision to give her an appointment of limited duration was manifestly unreasonable and therefore unlawful. The...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/032, McLetchie
Outcome: The application was rejected. The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT found that the Applicant failed to demonstrate that the implementation of the contested decision would cause her irreparable damage.
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/031, O'Hanlon
Starting date of the 90-day time limit to file an application: The Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT Statute, which prevails in case of contradiction with the Staff Rules as it is superior in the hierarchy of norms, prescribes that an application before the Tribunal must be filed within 90 days following receipt of the Administration¡¯s response to the request for management evaluation or, if the Administration has not replied to such request, following the expiry of the relevant response period for the management evaluation. If the Administration replies after the response period for the management evaluation but before...
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/030, Mirkovic
Effect of reversal of decision on compensation: Because the contested decision was reversed by the Administration does not necessarily mean that the applicant is not entitled to claim compensation for the damage s/he may have suffered as a result of the unlawful decision. In a case where the Administration reversed the contested decision at the management evaluation stage, if an applicant can prove that s/he still sustains or sustained an injury resulting from the unlawful decision despite the rescission of the same, s/he has grounds for claiming compensation.Outcome:
Ä¢¹½ÊÓÆµDT/2012/029, Diop
On the score of prima facie unlawfulness, having considered the facts of the case, the Tribunal held that everything pointed to a suspect reason for the non-renewal of the Applicant¡¯s contract. The Respondent did not give a clear reason for non-renewal, even after the Applicant specifically requested for it. The Tribunal, thus concluded that the decision not to renew the Applicant¡¯s contract was prima facie unlawful. With regard to particular urgency, the Tribunal found that this requirement was clearly met since the Applicant¡¯s contract was to expire on 29 February 2012. The Applicant had...